In practice, you should not subscribe to the same topic repeatedly, but try to subscribe to the same topic repeatedly in the test. If you find a problem, I am a beginner. Maybe it is not a problem. Looking forward to the answers. The broker and topic needs to be changed to yours [image]

Hi. I will check this but could you verify your what is ACTUALLY coming from broker by using an independent client? As you seem to be using MQTT v5 then I suggest MQTT X as it supports v5. Use a separate client to subscribe to topics v1/devices/me/attributes/request/1 and v1/devices/me/attributes/…

Please explain what problem you are seeing, and export a small flow demonstrating the problem. Then we can import it and see if we can replicate it.

The number is the execution order (click the execution order) After step 3, the data can be received normally, but the received data is lost when subscribing again (4-step, 5-step). If the data is repeated again (6-step, 7-step), the received data is empty [image] [{"id":"eafbf2bd0cb1a911","type…

Several more brokers are provided for testing by multiple people, which may not be connected to the broker { "broker": "thingsboard.cloud", "port": 1883, "force": true, "username": "2pbCdh3BI8SbsKD2iWzb", "protocolVersion": 5 } username guZYLGYDty9n51y0tYvx

Are they using the same client id, try leaving it blank in the broker

I confirm that thingboard is normal,I try unsub all, and then sub, and there will be no data or partial data.

In theory, the same client ID, no matter how many times you subscribe to the same topic, should also be the same topic, and the results should be normal. I'm a novice, maybe the description is wrong.You can try to change the sub to your business address

[image] joe1: I confirm that thingboard is normal,I How did you confirm this? Can you show screenshots? Are you using feature of MQTT v5? If not could you retest using v3.1? (protocolVersion = 4) I also tried the flow & sequence of operation with a mosquito broker - it works perfectly.

Your guess is correct. thingsboard's protocol is v3. Because of my carelessness, I connected v3 with v5. Thank you.

Node-RED

Node-RED Forum

Subscribe to the same topic multiple times and find problems

General

Steve-Mcl 6 November 2022 13:10 3

Please share this exact flow.

Also, please explain what you are attempting to achieve please.

Topic		Replies	Views
Repeated messages with Vernemq mqtt broker General	15	1796	17 July 2020
Problem with dynamic MQTT subscription: receiving messages from another topic! General mqtt	23	906	23 January 2023
MQTT - more messages than expected with overlapping topics General	13	777	25 October 2020
Mqtt-in repeated messages bug? General	16	2891	30 March 2019
I got an error related to mqtt subscription General	21	1522	28 May 2021

Copyright OpenJS Foundation and Node-RED contributors. All rights reserved. The OpenJS Foundation has registered trademarks and uses trademarks. For a list of trademarks of the OpenJS Foundation, please see our Trademark Policy and Trademark List. Trademarks and logos not indicated on the list of OpenJS Foundation trademarks are trademarks™ or registered® trademarks of their respective holders. Use of them does not imply any affiliation with or endorsement by them.

Subscribe to the same topic multiple times and find problems

Related topics